"Peshewa" hired a law firm and is making noises about suing. Which of course doesn't make her sound nervous at all about her claims being questioned.
Below is their two emails followed by my two responses.
---------
Dear Sir or Madam:
I am writing to you on behalf of Ms. Gowa Peshewa regarding false and derogatory statements published on your site about Ms. Peshewa’s race, ancestral lineage, and character. Such action can be construed as libel since you have expressed in written or other graphic form statements that tend to injure Ms. Peshewa’s character or reputation and thereby expose her to public hatred, contempt, or ridicule.
You are hereby given formal demand to remove all of such libelous statements from publication within seven (7) days and cease and desist from publishing such statements. If you continue to make such statements, Ms. Peshewa will have no alternative but to file suit against you for libel and to seek the full measure of her damages as permitted by law.
Very truly yours,
Merritt, Webb, Wilson & Caruso, PLLC
Shandi L. Fleeman
---------
Ms. Peshewa hereby renews her demand that you immediately remove such libelous statements from publication within forty-eight (48) hours and cease and desist from publishing such defamatory statements in the future.
Ms. Peshewa remains desirous of an amicable resolution in this matter; however, if you fail to timely resolve this matter with removal of the defamatory statements, Ms. Peshewa may be forced to pursue further legal action. You may forward your written confirmation of the resolution of this matter to our office. Thank you in advance for your immediate attention.
----------
This must be a record for incompetence by a law firm So many errors that a first year law student, or even the average layman, would not make.
1. It's been black letter law for over 50 years that either pointing out or arguing someone is a race or ethnicity other than what they claim is NOT libel. Only a racist who hates other races or believed them inferior would claim it is.
2. "Peshewa" is under Research Needed for almost two years. She's not under Frauds. At least not yet. That's because she's gone to some effort to hide her legal or birth name.
3. All the information in the Research Needed thread is reposted from other sites, including her own claims. Perhaps she should send empty legal threats based on bad lazy research to herself. Or to the many others who questions her claims.
4. So far all evidence points to her being a Rachel Dolezal type imposter. Her relatives are or were very obvious frauds, Jerry Dill and "Macaki." They were part of obviously fraudulent organizations, TN Indian Council, Remnant Band Shawnee, and NAC Strawberry Plains.
It takes all of five minutes to see that any of these organizations are either whites who are obvious imposters or whites who kid themselves based on dubious family stories. Your research is incredibly lazy, if you did any beyond naively taking her word.
5. Didn't the fact that she carefully avoids naming any alleged tribe set off alarms for you? Didn't her dressing in a bad imitation of Plains Indian regalia rather than as local tribes actually wear set off alarms? Or are you that ignorant of the most basic things about the claims of your client?
6. We do welcome all information that could clear up these matters. If she could give her actual legal birth name and her tribe, that would go a long way.
We'd also gladly post any statement of hers in the thread.
I'm going to post these emails between us so all can see.
It's also quite telling that she claims to be raising funds for public education and a nonprofit, but can afford a law firm.
------------
As a follow up I forgot to include in the previous email:
We have quite good genealogists. If "Peshewa" hasn't researched her claims of ancestry (clearly, her law firm lazily never did) we could do them for you .
Most white southerners with claims of Native ancestry actually have Black ancestors, usually because of a slaveowner who raped his slaves. They then tried to hide their Black ancestors because of their self hating racist shame at being part Black. This certainly would fit with her screaming "Libel!" the way segregationists and other white supremacists once did.
Truth is an absolute defense to libel. That's been black letter law for some time. We have no falsehoods on our site. In over 25 years we have never been sued. But we get empty threats to sue all the time that always lead to nothing.
We have members from dozens of tribes all over the US, Canada, Latin America, and Pacific Islanders, including academics, activists, and members of tribal and band gov'ts. We are widely used as a resource by universities, museums, news organizations, and people from all walks.
But then you would already know this if you actually read our site or researched us. So you may wish to actually question your client instead of wasting everyone's time some more.
We hope she'll be honest and tell us her legal birth name so we can research her family history and settle this matter.